top of page

Same Ingredients. Different Garments.

4 days ago
6 min read

Two garments can have all the same elements and still look so very different.
Two garments can have all the same elements and still look so very different.

Why small apparel design choices can make a big difference in fit, function, and fashion.


Recently, in my Fashion Forecasting class at FIT, I wanted to demonstrate how the same set of design details could produce dramatically different results. I sketched two jackets using exactly the same elements: four buttons, cuffs, notched lapels, and a front yoke. Yet they looked remarkably different.Then I asked my students to look closely and tell me what they saw.  


The jacket on the left was more traditional, with softer proportions and a familiar silhouette. The one on the right was more directional, with exaggerated shoulders, elongated lapels, and a sharper, more angular shape. Same ingredients, two very different outcomes.


What interested me most wasn't simply that the students recognized the differences. It was how they talked about them. After taking a moment to really look, the observations started coming. One jacket felt more ordinary, another looked more comfortable, while the one on the right was decidedly more fashionable.


And something else happens at this point in the semester that I love. Students become more comfortable speaking up, acknowledging one another's observations, and building on the conversation. I particularly lovegarment's character hearing someone begin with, "Building on that last point..." They're learning not just what to look for, but how to see, articulate, and discuss what they see. That skill goes well beyond the classroom. Learning to listen, articulate a point of view, and build on someone else's thinking will serve them in whatever they do next. All of us too.


The Difference Is in the Details. And What You Do With Them.


In apparel product development, we often start with a list of requirements. A particular silhouette, neckline, number of seams, closures, or functional features. Perhaps a fabric composition, an elastic width, or a specific piece of hardware. These details help define a product, but they don't necessarily determine what it will become.


Look again at the two jackets. The lapels weren't simply different sizes. Their proportions changed the relationship between the shoulders, neckline, and body. The placement of the yoke and the shape of the sleeves changed the entire silhouette. Neither jacket needed a different list of ingredients to establish its own identity.


The difference was in how those ingredients were interpreted and brought together.


And that's where some of the most interesting opportunities in apparel design exist.



Small Adjustments. Big Impact.


I'm currently designing an active tee for a client. It's a familiar product category, with plenty of options already available for running, working out, and everyday movement. So how do you make one feel distinctive without adding unnecessary complexity?


In this case, we introduced a new neckline detail and explored how it connected to the yoke seam and armhole. Rather than simply running the yoke parallel to the shoulder, we angled it more dramatically, aligning the neckline detail with the top of the yoke to create a stronger visual line toward the armhole.


It was a relatively small adjustment, but it changed the character of the garment. The tee still does what it's supposed to do, but now it has a little more personality, making it that much more appealing to wear. And yes, we're using an innovative fabric that delivers on the performance requirements. But we're not relying on the fabric alone to make the garment special.


It wasn't about adding more. It was about paying closer attention to what was already there.


Not every point of differentiation requires a new fabric, proprietary technology, or expensive component. Sometimes it's the width of an elastic, the placement of a seam, the scale of a closure, or the relationship between two existing details. These decisions aren't purely aesthetic, either. A seam can influence fit and movement, while an elastic can affect comfort and support. 


The best details often do double duty, contributing to both a garment's function and its fashion.


That's the sweet spot.


Apparel designer and product development consultant Suzy Wakefield working at her studio table, surrounded by dress forms, garments, and design materials. The workspace illustrates the hands-on process of exploring and refining apparel design details.
Sometimes I need to be heads down in the studio, figuring it all out, too.

Before You Add Something, Look Again


There's a temptation in product development to make something more distinctive by adding another feature, trim, or construction detail. But what if the opportunity is already there?


Could changing a proportion create a stronger silhouette? Could moving a seam improve the fit and appearance? Could an existing component, used differently, become a recognizable part of the product's identity?


Of course, these aren't necessarily cost-free decisions. Changes in construction, material consumption, or manufacturing operations can affect the bottom line. But a more distinctive design doesn't automatically have to cost more.


This is also why I encourage founders to sketch, even if they don't consider themselves designers. You don't need to produce a beautiful fashion illustration. Draw directly over a photograph of a garment. Move a seam, change a proportion, extend a neckline, or experiment with the placement of a detail. Put a few versions side by side and see what happens. Some of the most interesting ideas start with these simple explorations and become even better as we develop them further.


You may discover possibilities you hadn't considered, or realize that your original idea was the right one all along. Either way, you've learned something. And you'll have something much more concrete to discuss with your design and development team.

This connects to something I wrote about recently in The Questions You Don't Know to Ask Can Cost You the Most. The more you understand the possibilities and can communicate what you're trying to achieve, the more productive those conversations become.


Learning to See the Possibilities


Coming back to my students, the point of the jacket exercise wasn't to decide which design was better. It was to recognize how many different outcomes were possible using the same set of elements.


One jacket might appeal to a more traditional customer, while the other might attract someone looking for a stronger fashion statement. Neither is inherently more successful without understanding who the product is for and what it's meant to deliver. That's the importance of context, something I've explored before in Context Matters.


The same applies to founders developing their first product and established teams refining an existing collection. The goal isn't to make every garment more dramatic or complicated simply to be different. It's to recognize the possibilities within a design and choose what makes sense for the product, the customer, and the brand.


The next time you're reviewing a sketch, sample, or even a competitor's garment, look a little closer. What is each detail contributing visually? What is it doing functionally? Could a change in proportion, placement, or execution make the product more distinctive, more useful, or ideally, both?


You don't always need more ingredients to make a better product. Sometimes you need to see more possibilities in the ones you already have.



Three Questions Worth Asking at Your Next Development Meeting


Whether you're just starting or already deep into development, try these:


1. What are we assuming that we haven't actually confirmed? Fabric performance, sizing, manufacturing capabilities, customer expectations, or even the timeline.


2. Could this detail work harder? Beyond its visual impact, could changing the placement, proportion, or construction improve fit, comfort, or function?


3. Is there something I should understand better before we move forward? And turn it around: Is there something I haven't explained clearly enough about what I'm trying to achieve?


The Product Is the Result of the Conversation


A great product idea is a starting point. Execution is everything.


I've learned, sometimes the hard way, that being confident in your point of view and being willing to say I don't know aren't opposites. The strongest teams make room for both.


Ask the question. Share the concern. Challenge an assumption. And give the people around you room to bring their expertise to the table.


Because the questions nobody asks can become expensive mistakes. But the questions you do ask can make your product better than you first imagined.


If you're developing an apparel brand and want to explore how thoughtful design choices can make your product more distinctive, functional, and right for your customer, that's exactly the kind of work we do together. Book a call here to discuss your product and where we can help make the most of its potential.






 
 
 

Comments


GET IN THE KNOW

We want to share tips, tricks, and advice so you stay in the know.

  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram

OUR BRAND

©2020 by Suzy Wakefield Designs. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page